What gefilte fish is, how it is made from ground fish, horseradish on the side, and tips for Shabbat and Passover.
Gefilte fish is a traditional Jewish dish of ground fish mixed with onion and egg, shaped into balls or a loaf, simmered, and served cold with horseradish. It is a classic first course at Shabbat and holiday meals in Jewish homes in Oakland and around the world.
What is gefilte fish?
“Gefilte” (געפילטע) is Yiddish for “stuffed.” The dish is made from ground fish, onions, eggs, salt and sugar. It is served cold, with a slice of cooked carrot on top and chrein (חריין), a sharp horseradish and beet relish, on the side. Some people consider it the quintessential Jewish food. It is a fish dish, so the fish must be kosher; see our guide to kosher fish.
Why on Shabbat?
Fish is a long-standing food of the Shabbat table, and many Jewish families make gefilte fish for Friday night or Shabbat lunch. People give a number of explanations for the custom, so ask the Rabbi if you would like to hear more. For the full picture of the meal, see Shabbat meals and Jewish foods.
Homemade gefilte fish
This recipe makes about 60 fish balls, and it halves easily.
Fish mixture – 5 pounds ground fish (the recipe uses a mix of pike and whitefish) – 2 medium onions, peeled and ground – 2 tablespoons kosher salt – 5 eggs – 3 tablespoons water – 1 1/2 cups sugar
Cooking stock – 16 cups water – 4 teaspoons kosher salt – 1/2 cup sugar – 2 onions and 2 carrots, peeled and cut into chunks
Use kosher ingredients, and ask the Rabbi about specifics.
Steps 1. Bring the stock ingredients to a boil in a big, sturdy pot. 2. Mix the fish ingredients. The mixture should be soft but firm enough to roll into balls. 3. When the stock is boiling hard, gently drop in the fish balls, a few at a time. Wet your hands now and then to make rolling easier. 4. When all the balls are in, lower the heat and simmer for one hour. 5. Lift out the fish and carrots and let them cool. Throw out the liquid. 6. Refrigerate for up to 3 days, or freeze for later.
Matzah meal: this recipe has none, since many people do not wet matzah on Passover. Outside Passover, or if you do not keep that custom, you can fold in about half a cup of matzah meal, a little at a time, to firm the mixture.
Serving, and a Passover note
Serve it chilled, with the carrot and chrein. Because this version has no matzah meal, it is made to suit Passover, and families often prepare it ahead for the Seder. See the Passover shopping list and Passover. Whether you may eat certain ingredients on Passover is a question for the Rabbi.
Common questions
What is gefilte fish?
Gefilte fish is ground fish mixed with onion and egg, formed into balls or a loaf, and simmered. It is served cold with horseradish.
What does gefilte mean?
Gefilte is Yiddish for “stuffed.” Ask the Rabbi if you would like more about the name.
Why do Jews eat gefilte fish on Shabbat?
Fish is a traditional food of Shabbat and holiday meals. Explanations differ, so ask the Rabbi.
Is gefilte fish kosher?
It is kosher only if the fish and all ingredients are kosher. See kosher fish, and ask the Rabbi about specifics.
Can I make gefilte fish ahead of time?
Yes. It keeps in the refrigerator for up to 3 days, and it freezes well.
What do you eat gefilte fish with?
Traditionally with chrein, a horseradish and beet relish, and a piece of cooked carrot.
Take the next step
- Try a full Shabbat menu: chicken soup and kugel.
- Sign up for a Shabbat meal and taste it with friends.
- Questions? Call Chabad of Oakland at 510-545-6770.
